I have smelled this side by side by sb extreme. It is very close about 80-90% close. On initial spray its all over the place but give it 15 mins and the aroma becmoes almost indistinguishable. The only issue is i think the pp version hass less vanilla so smells spicier ever so slightly but this is side by side. Do not get the oil roll as i think that throws off the scent. Better of getting the spray.